Tajikam Worldwide Community

General => General Discussion => Topic started by: Gul agha on October 24, 2007, 09:15:55 PM



Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Gul agha on October 24, 2007, 09:15:55 PM
Would you rather have a Greater Khorasan or a Greater Tajikistan?


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nader Shah on October 24, 2007, 09:42:51 PM
I would rather have a greater Iran.


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nastoh on October 25, 2007, 11:08:27 AM
Greater Khorasan would be better. I am against "afghanistan" as a name and "Afghan" as a nationality. I believe it's wrong to call a country of minorities after an ethnic.


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Rostam on October 28, 2007, 04:46:41 PM
Quote from: Nastoh;2377
Greater Khorasan would be better. I am against "afghanistan" as a name and "Afghan" as a nationality. I believe it's wrong to call a country of minorities after an ethnic.

Absolutely right!

I prefer something which can be justified by law, logic, reason etc.
Doesnt matter, if it can be justified then there is no doubt that it must be good!


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Mahasti on October 29, 2007, 08:36:15 AM
I would rather have northern afghanistan separated from southern afghanistan.


Title: Greater Khurasan ... ???
Post by: Nader Shah on November 03, 2007, 09:10:33 PM
Ah, now our dear awghans claim to want a greater khurasan ... interesting, but whose land will be there and which army will conquer it ? undoubtedly there is an army of wheelchair rocking awghans on this site who will volunteer to fight in cyberspace: good luck ! What about the land - whose land will you take ? Well, how about Eastern Iran ? Hm... but then why not the whole of Iran ? And then where will hte capital of nbew khorasan be in  ? In Qandahar/Kabul ? In Tehran ? In Dushanbe (I think those people are smart enough not to be polluted with awghans who claim to be tajik). So, tell us more about your plans. Sounds like the ideal comic discussion ... maybe it could be moved to Jokistan ???


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Afrasiab on November 05, 2007, 04:11:55 AM
Quote from: doodooli;2593
Ah, now our dear awghans claim to want a greater khurasan ... interesting, but whose land will be there and which army will conquer it ? undoubtedly there is an army of wheelchair rocking awghans on this site who will volunteer to fight in cyberspace: good luck ! What about the land - whose land will you take ? Well, how about Eastern Iran ? Hm... but then why not the whole of Iran ? And then where will hte capital of nbew khorasan be in  ? In Qandahar/Kabul ? In Tehran ? In Dushanbe (I think those people are smart enough not to be polluted with awghans who claim to be tajik). So, tell us more about your plans. Sounds like the ideal comic discussion ... maybe it could be moved to Jokistan ???


Aghai doodooli, uzr keh ba tajiki menavisam.

Albatta mo tajikhai minqa, keh shumoramon to ba 30-40 million nafar merasad, ayni hol suolu mushkilihai ziyod dorem dar rohi ittihod va ta'sisi Khurosoni Buzurg. Vale mo ohista-ohista hamaro hall khohem kard va beshtar bo ham khohem omad. Oyandai ittihodi tajikii mo az hamin forumi Tajiki oghoz meshavad.

Mavzui poytakhti (capital) davlati Tajikha Kabul khohad bud yo Dushanbe, in mavzui fardost va mo onro muvofiqi khohishi aksariyat hal khohem kard. Mo shoad dar davlati Tajiki yakchand poytakht khgohem dosht: poytakhti shimoli (Samarqand), poytakhti janubi (Kabul), poytakhti gharbi (Hirot) va poytakhti sharqi (Dushanbe).

Dar amoni Khudo


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Afrasiab on November 05, 2007, 04:12:30 AM
Quote from: doodooli;2593
Ah, now our dear awghans claim to want a greater khurasan ... interesting, but whose land will be there and which army will conquer it ? undoubtedly there is an army of wheelchair rocking awghans on this site who will volunteer to fight in cyberspace: good luck ! What about the land - whose land will you take ? Well, how about Eastern Iran ? Hm... but then why not the whole of Iran ? And then where will hte capital of nbew khorasan be in  ? In Qandahar/Kabul ? In Tehran ? In Dushanbe (I think those people are smart enough not to be polluted with awghans who claim to be tajik). So, tell us more about your plans. Sounds like the ideal comic discussion ... maybe it could be moved to Jokistan ???


Aghai doodooli, uzr keh ba tajiki menavisam.

Albatta mo tajikhai mintaqa, keh shumoramon to ba 30-40 million nafar merasad, ayni hol suolu mushkilihai ziyod dorem dar rohi ittihod va ta'sisi Khurosoni Buzurg. Vale mo ohista-ohista hamaro hall khohem kard va beshtar bo ham khohem payvast. Oyandai ittihodi tajikii mo az hamin forumi Tajiki oghoz meshavad.

Mavzui poytakhti (capital) davlati Tajikha Kabul khohad bud yo Dushanbe, in mavzui fardost va mo onro muvofiqi khohishi aksariyat hal khohem kard. Mo shoad dar davlati Tajiki yakchand poytakht khgohem dosht: poytakhti shimoli (Samarqand), poytakhti janubi (Kabul), poytakhti gharbi (Hirot) va poytakhti sharqi (Dushanbe).

Dar amoni Khudo


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nastoh on November 05, 2007, 01:08:46 PM
doste aziz Afrasiab,
ba gofta hayat kamelan mowafeqat daram. Tashakor.
Quote from: Afrasiab;2609
Aghai doodooli, uzr keh ba tajiki menavisam.
 
Albatta mo tajikhai minqa, keh shumoramon to ba 30-40 million nafar merasad, ayni hol suolu mushkilihai ziyod dorem dar rohi ittihod va ta'sisi Khurosoni Buzurg. Vale mo ohista-ohista hamaro hall khohem kard va beshtar bo ham khohem omad. Oyandai ittihodi tajikii mo az hamin forumi Tajiki oghoz meshavad.
 
Mavzui poytakhti (capital) davlati Tajikha Kabul khohad bud yo Dushanbe, in mavzui fardost va mo onro muvofiqi khohishi aksariyat hal khohem kard. Mo shoad dar davlati Tajiki yakchand poytakht khgohem dosht: poytakhti shimoli (Samarqand), poytakhti janubi (Kabul), poytakhti gharbi (Hirot) va poytakhti sharqi (Dushanbe).
 
Dar amoni Khudo


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nader Shah on November 05, 2007, 10:19:11 PM
Quote from: Afrasiab;2610
Aghai doodooli, uzr keh ba tajiki menavisam.

Albatta mo tajikhai mintaqa, keh shumoramon to ba 30-40 million nafar merasad, ayni hol suolu mushkilihai ziyod dorem dar rohi ittihod va ta'sisi Khurosoni Buzurg. Vale mo ohista-ohista hamaro hall khohem kard va beshtar bo ham khohem payvast. Oyandai ittihodi tajikii mo az hamin forumi Tajiki oghoz meshavad.

Mavzui poytakhti (capital) davlati Tajikha Kabul khohad bud yo Dushanbe, in mavzui fardost va mo onro muvofiqi khohishi aksariyat hal khohem kard. Mo shoad dar davlati Tajiki yakchand poytakht khgohem dosht: poytakhti shimoli (Samarqand), poytakhti janubi (Kabul), poytakhti gharbi (Hirot) va poytakhti sharqi (Dushanbe).

Dar amoni Khudo


What about Neishabour, Tous, and Mashad ? What happens to those places ? Are they not part of Khorasan ? If they are part of Khorasan, then do you think they are so different from the rest of Iran ? Do you think khorasanis of Iran don't feel Iranian ? I doubt it ... so what is the boundary of your future country ? Why is Mashhad not its eastern or southern capital ?


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nader Shah on November 05, 2007, 10:24:07 PM
I Meant Western Capital For Mashhad. Is It Because It Is Shia ? So, Is Your Khorasan A Sunni Khorasan ? Is It About Sunnism Or About Khorasan ? Why Do You Think Khorasan Is Not Iran ? Iranians Think You People Are Not Real Khorassanis ... Maybe Just A Bunch Of Uzbeks And Mongols And Indians With A Little Bit Of Tajik. The Tajiks Of Uzbekistan And Tajikistan Don't Have A Big Problem With Iran. They May Be Closer To Tajiks Of Afghanistan But Many Of Them They Seek To Be United With Their Iranian Brothers And Sisters, As Well As With Their Afghan Brothers And Sisters. So What Is Wrong Here With This Greater Khurasan Idea ? What Has Affghanistan Done For Persians ? Not Much. What Has Tajikistan Done ? Much Much More !!


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Khurasan
Post by: Kokcha on November 06, 2007, 03:14:12 AM
Dear Hamwatan: I truely appreciate your sense of nationalism. But as you know, none of those dreams are easy or even possible, at least for a long long time to fulfill. I think we need to focus on issues which are really important for Tajiks everywhere especially in Afghanistan. No hard feelings, please don't led us to day dreaming.


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Laila-Bukharai on November 08, 2007, 06:35:52 AM
Great Tajikistan


Title: Great Tajikistan
Post by: Laila-Bukharai on November 08, 2007, 06:36:45 AM
Great Tajikistan


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Parsistani on November 14, 2007, 01:03:45 PM
Quote from: Gul agha;2363
Would you rather have a Greater Khorasan or a Greater Tajikistan?


I think it depends if other persian speaking nation will join us or not. If Hazara people want also be part than i am for Greater Khorasan if they don


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Parsistani on November 15, 2007, 10:48:17 AM
Doodooli, it was never our mentaliy to talk about sunni and shia crap. that


Title: Greater Tajikistan or Greater Khorasan
Post by: Nastoh on November 16, 2007, 01:44:50 PM
One of them. It doesn't really matter.